Thursday, April 9, 2015

Can the provision of breakfast benefit school performance?

PubMed - NCBI

Food Nutr Bull. 2005 Jun;26(2 Suppl 2):S144-58.
Can the provision of breakfast benefit school performance?
Grantham-McGregor.

Abstract

Studies
of an association between school performance (enrollment, attendance,
achievement, classroom behavior, and school drop-out) and nutritional
status are discussed and the evidence of an effect of school meals
evaluated. Many studies have shown associations between hunger, poor
dietary intakes, stunting, underweight, and poor school performance
after controlling for socioeconomic conditions. However, it remains
possible that unmeasured socioeconomic variables could explain the
relationship. Rigorous short-term studies of missing breakfast have
generally found detrimental effects on children's cognition whereas
studies of providing breakfast have shown benefits particularly in
malnourished children. Classroom conditions may modify the effects of
breakfast on behavior. There are extremely few longer term studies of
the effects of giving school meals. Nearly all involved breakfast and
very few had randomized controlled designs. Studies comparing
participants with non-participants or comparing matched schools have
found benefits (but bias due to self-selection) of receiving breakfast;
inadequate matching of schools also remains possible. One longer term
randomized controlled trial found benefits associated with attendance
and arithmetic performance. In conclusion, most studies of giving
breakfast have found benefits to school performance but many had serious
design problems, were short-term, and were not conducted in the poorest
countries. In order to advise policy makers correctly, there is an
urgent need to run long-term randomized controlled trials of giving
school meals in poor countries and to determine the effects of age and
nutrition status of the children, the quality of the school, and the
timing of the meal. The special needs of orphans should also be
considered.

No comments:

Post a Comment